Should Walcott or Beckham Start vs Croatia?

September 7th, 2008 | by: Daryl |

Bit of a debate in The Sun today about whether Walcott or Beckham should start on England’s right wing vs Croatia. Theo Walcott had his moments on the right wing vs Andorra. But anyone that quick is always going to have a few moments, especially against Andorra. And though he looked dangerous, he wasn’t necessarily effective.

Losing isn’t really an option for Capello, unless he wants to be labeled as “Steve McClaren with a funny accent.” (actually, there’s already a Steve McClaren with a funny accent isn’t there.)

So maybe there’s an argument for replacing the inexperienced Walcott with the ultra-experienced Beckham? He’s a veteran of several qualifying campaigns after all, and wasn’t allowed to play the last time England visited Zagreb. And we all know how that worked out.

But it’s hard to escape the fact that Beckham is now a limited player. He can still serve up a mean set piece, but no longer seems threatening enough to warrant a place in the team for that reason alone.

So basically it’s the pacy but ineffective Walcott vs the slow but not quite as effective as he once was Beckham. Who should start at right mid for England? I vote for Joe Cole.

England Football Team World Cup Blog RSS Feed

http://www.tsheets.com Time Tracker

Becks has had his time…I say let Walcott on the pitch first and see what he can pull off. Besides, Becks needs to be home by midnight, otherwise Posh gets a bit testy.
Mel Slade

Lay off Theo he played well, ineffective you say- he set up 4 chances to 4 ineffective strikers today u idiot
http://leeds.theoffside.com j

Theo – hands down. Respectfully, Becks isn’t at this level now and I’m not even sure he could play in the Premier League full time.
http://www.worldcupblog.org Daryl

Theo over Joe Cole as well? Or Joe Cole on the left? Or maybe Cole as part of five man midfield?
http://www.worldcupblog.org Daryl

Mel Slade,

What’s with the “u idiot” ? Fine to have your opinion, and fine to disagree. But no need to get personal.
dave

Walcott over Beckham
http://sisterhoodoftravelingpantsuit.com/ Jess

Daryl, don’t be upset with “Mel Slade” as he might be a brilliant humourist. Why else would he comment “u idiot” if he wasn’t making fun of a situation as surely he wouldn’t use “u” for “you” and then call you an idiot. Delightful sarcastic wit
http://epl.theoffside.com Rob

Joe Cole and Theo Walcott, as part of a five man midfield. Away we really should be playing 451.
ghost of steve finnan

here is the best team :
James

Johnson Terry Lescott(Rio when healthy)Cole

Walcott Barry Lampard(Gerrard when healthy)Young

Agbonlahor Rooney
Eirik

The best England line-up:

Hart
Johnson Ferdinand Terry Bridge
Bentley Barry Gerrard Cole
Lampard
Agbonlahor
MATT

Beckham to start and give a bit of structure and backbone to the team, let him play til 60 mins, bring on Theo to run past the tired croatian defence and whip some balls in and cause some havoc, we need to play as a team and beckham has an ability that no other does in the squad. And Theo has the energy to keep things going til the final whistle…………… A good dilemma choosing between the two so lets enjoy the game
Lisa

THEO….Need we say any more….proven