dot   Home     World     Europe     England  
Flag England

England

Jermain Defoe: Good at Scoring Goals, But Good Enough to Start for England?

Spurs beat Wigan 9-1 (not a typo) this weekend with England’s own Jermain Defoe backing five of the goals. A hat-trick and two thirds of way to another hat-trick.

My favourite thing about those five is the range it demonstrates in Defoe’s finishing: From movement in the box to close range acrobatics to sniper like accuracy from a wide angle. No doubt about it, Jermain Defoe is good at scoring goals.

But good enough to start for England?

In terms of pure goalscoring, I say yes. But with the system England currently play, there’s still no place for him in the first XI. It’s Rooney behind a big man. And Defoe is not a big man. It’s that simple.

The current system is built around Wayne Rooney. It’s no coincidence that Rooney scored nine goals in 10 World Cup qualifying games. The system works because he has a big man to play off of, and – like it or not – that man is Emile Heskey.

Including Defoe means changing the system. Essentially it means changing the system to suit Defoe instead of Rooney. Assuming we can agree that Rooney is the superior and more complete player, it’s very difficult to argue that building a team around Defoe is a smart idea.

I hope no one reads this post and thinks I’m anti-Defoe. I’m really really not. I think he’s fantastic. But that doesn’t mean I want England to change the way we’ve been playing.

What I do want to see, and what I think we will see, is Defoe on the bench at the World Cup. But also Defoe coming off the bench to either win games or rescue games. There’s no shame in that. Because if you want to go far in a World Cup, then sometimes Plan B is either as important or even more important than Plan A.

Subscribe

 

rss icon England Football Team World Cup Blog RSS Feed

Print

Share

Comments
By vernon @ football social network | November 23rd, 2009 at 1:51 pm
Top

It s a strange way to go on when the forwards on the bench are far more likely to score than the ones that are picked to start. Pretty much everybody on the pitch is more likely to score than Heskey. Defoe and Crouch are both more likely to score than Rooney. So is Lampard come to that.
Lets pick forwards that can score.

By Martin | November 23rd, 2009 at 4:21 pm
Top

And spurs is built around Defoe? How?

By AnanOfCourse | November 23rd, 2009 at 4:49 pm
Top

@Vernon
Couldn’t have said it better myself. We seem intent on fielding team that we want to do well for us rather than the one that actually will.

Posted from United Kingdom United Kingdom

By Zac | November 23rd, 2009 at 6:06 pm
Top

There’s got to be a way to fit the best possible players into the scheme, or at least fitting the best combination of players, rather than tailoring everything around one player. I’m not smart enough to know what it is, but there must be a happy medium which utilizes both Rooney and Defoe, and even if that means neither of them are utilizing 100 % of their potential it might be the case that 70-80% of Rooney and Defoe are greater than the sum of 100% of Rooney and %100 of Heskey.

Posted from United States United States

By seif | November 28th, 2009 at 1:38 pm
Top

England have a problem in the goalkeeping area and should really take a look at STEVE HARPER. He is doing fantastically well for Newcastle this season: only 10 goals conceded in 18 games played!! He looks as if he is the only English GK capable of match-winning performances (look at his performance against Sheffield United!!).Capello looked at Mancienne when he was at Wolves in the Championship and i don’t see why he shouldn’t try Harper in the friendly in march…

Comments are closed

 
 
 

MORE EUROPE BLOGS

france
France World Cup Blog
820 articles | 10,859 comments
 
croatia
Croatia World Cup Blog
200 articles | 1,848 comments
 
czechrepublic
Czech Republic World Cup Blog
196 articles | 321 comments
 
england
England Football Team World Cup Blog
883 articles | 3,198 comments
 
germany
Germany World Cup Blog Blog
528 articles | 3,274 comments
 
italy
Italy World Cup Blog
624 articles | 23,788 comments
 
netherlands
Netherlands World Cup Blog
2,091 articles | 31,318 comments
 
poland
Poland World Cup Blog
374 articles | 4,745 comments
 
portugal
Portugal World Cup Blog
462 articles | 7,141 comments
 
serbia
Serbia World Cup Team Blog
173 articles | 888 comments
 
spain
Spain World Cup Blog
236 articles | 1,946 comments
 
sweden
Sweden World Cup Blog
151 articles | 319 comments
 
switzerland
Switzerland World Cup Blog
227 articles | 353 comments
 
ukraine
Ukraine World Cup Team Blog
120 articles | 809 comments
 
greece
Greece World Cup Blog
147 articles | 80 comments
 
russia
Russia World Cup Blog
82 articles | 159 comments
 
scotland
Scotland World Cup Team Blog
104 articles | 112 comments
 
ireland
Ireland World Cup Team Blog
62 articles | 130 comments
 
norway
Norway World Cup Team Blog
13 articles | 8 comments
 
turkey
Turkey World Cup Blog
40 articles | 296 comments
 
romania
Romania World Cup Blog
78 articles | 281 comments
 
austria
Austria World Cup Blog
111 articles | 118 comments
 
denmark
Denmark World Cup Team Blog
13 articles | 32 comments
 
albania
Albania World Cup Team Blog
4 articles | 8 comments
 
belgium
Belgium World Cup Team Blog
49 articles | 59 comments
 
wales
Wales World Cup Team Blog
61 articles | 17 comments
 
bosnia
Bosnia World Cup Team Blog
31 articles | 89 comments
 
israel
Israel World Cup Team Blog
23 articles | 20 comments
 
slovakia
Slovakia World Cup Team Blog
3 articles | 2 comments
 
slovenia
Slovenia World Cup Team Blog
7 articles | 19 comments
 

CATEGORIES & ARCHIVES

 
 
Closer