Brian Clough: The Best Manager England Never Had

April 9th, 2009 | by: Daryl |

I still struggle to get my head around the fact that Brian Clough never managed the England team. He was the greatest manager of his generation and he desperately wanted the job. But he never got it.

Imagine if Clough was around today? An Englishman who wins trophies? The FA would be tripping over their expensive shoes to get him in an England blazer. But not in 1977.

Clough’s nemesis Don Revie resigned from the England job in ‘77 having failed to qualify for Euro ‘76 and all but failed to qualify for World Cup ‘78. Revie walked out on his disastrous reign and into a nice payday managing the United Arab Emirates. It seemed the perfect time for Clough to take over.

This video (taken from ITV’s recent “Clough” documentary) tells the story. Go to the 10:00 mark and watch from there.

(That’s part three of four. You can see the whole documentary via these links at Football Filter – definitely worth a watch…)

Ron Greenwood got the job instead, and didn’t do too badly. He nearly rescued the ‘78 World Cup qualification campaign (beating Italy and just missing out on goal difference) and the qualifying for Euro ‘80 and World Cup ‘82.

But for me the job should have been Clough’s when Greenwood stepped down in 1982. In the intervening years Clough had won back to back European Cups with Nottingham Forest (79′ and ‘80) and was arguably in the prime of his career.

Bobby Robson got the job instead, but after failing to qualify for Euro ‘84 Robson apparently offered to resign so Clough could take over. The FA said no. Robson lead us to a decent World Cup Mexico ‘86, a horrible Euro ‘88 and a brilliant World Cup Italia ‘90. But I can’t help thinking how much better that England team (the one of Robson, Lineker, Barnes etc) would have performed under Old Big ‘Ed.

Why didn’t he get the job? It’s not really a big mystery, and Clough himself probably said it best:

“I’m sure the England selectors thought if they took me on and gave me the job, then I would want to run the show.

“They were shrewd because that is exactly what I would have done.”

England Football Team World Cup Blog RSS Feed

http://epl.theoffside.com Wayne

Good post, great documentary. He would honestly have been an unbelievable England manager. if he was around today he’d get the job, Mourinho’s the nearest thing we’ve got and we all know how much the FA wanted him.
http://epl.theoffside.com Rob

The Damned United was a really good film too.
http://epl.theoffside.com Wayne

I haven’t seen it yet. Can’t wait though. might try and download it online over the weekend. From what I’ve seen (trailers) Michael Sheen appears to have Clough down.
Miguel Rosado

Hello. I’m from Mexico and I’ve been following England for a while now, you guys have the best leaders in the world (Terry, Gerrard, Lampard, Rio, etc.). I have seen a huge change in your team since Capello took the job and I actually think you’ll be very hard to beat next summer.

I also watched England’s games when Sven was your coach. Sven has just been sacked from the Mexican national team.

My question is what can you tell me about Sven Goran Erickson? Is he a good coach? did you like him when he was with the English team?.
http://www.worldcupblog.org Daryl

Miguel,

I can’t speak for everyone, but here is how I remember Sven’s time as England manager:

He started well by qualifying for World Cup 2002 but we soon became frustrated with his approach. It was always 4-4-2 with very little imagination to our play. There was no Plan B. Whether winning or losing it was the same formation and tactics.

Even worse, the big name players were always picked and always played. Even if they weren’t in good form or were still half-injured (eg Beckham at 2002 WC and Rooney at 2006 WC). Sven’s plan always seemed to be: get the big names on the pitch and that will be good enough. The result was some very dull football.

He didn’t do well with the press either, having a few high profile affairs and also being caught negotiating with a (fake) representative to leave England and take a new job. Pretty much no one was sad to see him leave in 2006.